Member of the Faculty of Islamic Azad University of Karaj
10.22034/jep.2025.501532.1649
Abstract
The hadith known as the hadith of the will is the main evidence of Ahmad Basri and his followers for his truthfulness. They consider this hadith to be a testament of the Holy Prophet that it has become a "diagnostic text" due to the description of Asim Man al-Dalal, and it is impossible to cite it falsely, and the claimant of falsehood will perish. As a result, since Ahmad Basri cited this hadith and it was not destroyed, he is right. in thisThe writing assumes that the hadith of the will is attributed to the Holy Prophet, firstly its description as "Asim min al-Dalal" has been examined and it has been shown that the transfer of this description to the hadith of the will is solely based on the evidence of the Sunnis in the matter of the pen and duwat. has taken place, although there is the opposite in Shia sources. In the Shiite sources, this flow and the writing of a will after that, all of them It happened on Monday - the day of the passing away of the Holy Prophet - not before that and between Thursday and Sunday night. Therefore, in addition to the hadith of the will, which is related to Sunday night, it is reported from another letter that was written on Monday, that it is the same will of Asim min al-Dalal that the Holy Prophet intended.
movahedi,A A . (2023). Illusion of succession - a critique on the main reason for the legitimacy of the Yemenite sect. Emamat Pajouhi, 13(1), 97-130. doi: 10.22034/jep.2025.501532.1649
MLA
movahedi,A A . "Illusion of succession - a critique on the main reason for the legitimacy of the Yemenite sect", Emamat Pajouhi, 13, 1, 2023, 97-130. doi: 10.22034/jep.2025.501532.1649
HARVARD
movahedi A A. (2023). 'Illusion of succession - a critique on the main reason for the legitimacy of the Yemenite sect', Emamat Pajouhi, 13(1), pp. 97-130. doi: 10.22034/jep.2025.501532.1649
CHICAGO
A A movahedi, "Illusion of succession - a critique on the main reason for the legitimacy of the Yemenite sect," Emamat Pajouhi, 13 1 (2023): 97-130, doi: 10.22034/jep.2025.501532.1649
VANCOUVER
movahedi A A. Illusion of succession - a critique on the main reason for the legitimacy of the Yemenite sect. Emamat Pajouhi. 2023;13(1):97-130 (In Persian). doi: 10.22034/jep.2025.501532.1649